May 12, 2009

霹雳州政府的合法性

霹雳变天至今疑点重重,无论在法、理、情方面都还没有一致答案和看法,然而在一般的角度而言,整个变天的合法性是操控在国阵政府手上,甚至指昨天高庭的裁决乃国阵政府所施的“计中计”,先让社会认同司法,认同高庭裁决,然后同样用上司法,如上诉庭和联邦法院推翻民联州务大臣,最后国阵补上一句“你看!司法是公正的!”。

到目前为止霹雳州政府掌控权的演变还是一个谜,可是变天过程便留下很多疑点,国阵政府无法确定及解释的何止是州务大臣的合法性,打从开始便是疑团:

一)议员是在代表民联(蓝眼和火箭)竞选获胜,从注册竞选、宣传和中选都是用上民联的标志,没有标志,没有代表注册的政党,连提名表格都不合法,所以跳槽本无效;议员在没有跳槽法令和宪法赋予下可以自由选择政党,可是竞选表格上“所代表单位”一旦改变,连划票上的标志也一样被否定,中选的不是标志上的议员,无法合法化议员的代表,自然无法合理化变天;

二)在州统治者撤换州务大臣后,民联议长曾经以议长身份禁止7个议员进入州议会,国阵在之后证实这项决定是违反议长权力,毕竟没有召开州议会,议长不可行使有关权力,这项决定虽不能左右变天,可是却将决定5月初召开的会议,在这7人的出席下会议是否合法

三)5月初州议会的召开也是疑团重重,会议通知书可以是关键,如果州会议在变天之前由民联政府订下(州议会可能在之前已经订下一年的开会时间表),只要国阵州务大臣不在信件上签名,同时在没有议长签署下,由其他人召集会议,会议是否合法?

四)州议会开会程序不符,会议开始必须由议长主持,无论喜欢不喜欢,开会没有进入议程之前没有通过任何临时动议的可能;有一种情况就是开会之前已有通过提成临时动议,在议会开始之前已经将有关动议及内容分发给所有议员,可是在霹雳王储还没有致上开幕词之前,理应不能有任何临时动议;

五)议长在台上,身位副议长的许月凤不能行使本身权力;这事件上可能技术上合理,副议长是可以取代议长,可是必须符合程序,毕竟副议长的权力是在“没有议长”的情况下方可以动用,“关麦”和“搬走议长”,并不是副议长主持会议的合法角度;

六)州议会遴选国阵议长的决定及合法性将会是另一个高潮,在种种疑团下产生的议长是否合法?如果合法以议长身份是否有权利召开紧急会议罢免民联州务大臣?没有经过会议所召集的紧急会议是否又似民联议长禁议员进入会议厅的决定,不合法呢?
这些层层的疑团存在,即使国阵有办法在高庭判决后扭转乾坤,重夺政权,也无法平息人民心中怒火,政府本来就是人民所选,代表人民,如今国阵为了表面的权力,抹杀人民的感受,值得吗?

37 comments:

  1. 在这紧要关头竟然让民联获胜?
    事情应该没有那么简单的啦!
    大家还记得霹雳州变天前夕的那场跳了进去又跳出来的跳槽闹剧吗?
    民联,小心乐极生悲!

    ReplyDelete
  2. mca people also "pretend" good and understanding?

    keykok you yesterday baru argue appointment of "new speaker" on 507is legal?

    If you mca so good ask Dr Mah stop all this idiot action and talk!

    But too late, these idiot talk and action has caused demange from 204 to 507.

    Today ask keykok pretend good in order to cover xxx?

    ReplyDelete
  3. 我忍你们BN。。。下届大选等着瞧吧!

    ReplyDelete
  4. 分析得有理,这真的有可能是国阵的“茅招”!

    ReplyDelete
  5. 我都说了,戏只做到一半。还有下半场呢!
    振国兄,你上载的国阵中指标志很有意思,小心被你老总踢出马华。哈哈

    ReplyDelete
  6. 国阵一开始就非法夺权,然后以不合理的行为,合法化一切不合理的仪程。再告诉大家,国阵是合法的政府。如果上诉庭推翻高庭的判决。
    最后大家都得接受国阵是合法的政府。
    因为法律是公平的。

    ReplyDelete
  7. 你的分析是真的吗?我还替法官担心,认为他这次有难了。

    ReplyDelete
  8. 目前,很多还是虚幻。

    ReplyDelete
  9. 赞成S.A.N.G 所说的,这可能是国阵给霹雳人民的“一时的爽快”,可是一时的爽快,并不代表永远的快乐,“明日你就知死”。

    今日上诉庭允许赞比里的暂缓执行申请,就把高庭的裁决打回原形。

    ReplyDelete
  10. 其实是预料之内.......

    ReplyDelete
  11. 最終還是還政予民.誰才是愛民的政府,衹有人民知道.別玩過火了.政治人物別自毀前程.當人民忍無可忍時,將會是惊天動地的反擊.好自為之.

    ReplyDelete
  12. keykok said...
    其实是预料之内.......


    and you still "sleep" with evil?? oic you are one of them.

    gosh

    ReplyDelete
  13. wait few day, i already draft my resign letter......

    ReplyDelete
  14. 哈哈!振国兄,觉得您越来越有幽默感。

    ReplyDelete
  15. 哈哈!

    真的写了,还没有轮到.....

    ReplyDelete
  16. 真是无法无天。你说的本是真理呀。。。但是,可以上诉那么快。。。还是没眼看咯。。。一万个理由又如何呀。。。笑到最后的人才是赢家。。。三年后吧。。。

    ReplyDelete
  17. 这政治手法,多年不变,味道还是这样“腥”。

    ReplyDelete
  18. keykok said...
    wait few day, i already draft my resign letter......


    Talk only, no action!

    ReplyDelete
  19. keykok, do not forget to publish your resignation letter so that others can copy. as well, let us know where you are heading and why? :)

    ReplyDelete
  20. keykok said....

    NATO

    ReplyDelete
  21. haha!


    i am ready, maybe weekend.....

    ReplyDelete
  22. Many people expected that!

    This is just a BN's TRICKS!

    See what Naji$ said yesterday when high court announced the result. He is so confident saying that You all don't be too 'terlebih suka'
    (eg., Don't be too happy first) Obviously, he has planned the agenda for all these processes.

    今日上诉庭允许赞比里的暂缓执行申请,就把高庭的裁决打回原形。
    See...this is actually what we expected already, just the time matter. Guess what is the next? I'm sure you know the answer already, so let's wait and see...

    ReplyDelete
  23. keykok said...
    haha!
    i am ready, maybe weekend.....

    How many times i have to remind that you are typical mca idxx, TALK ONLY BOH ACTION???

    Even talk also all kind of nonsense....look at Dr Mah, then we all know the definition of NONSENSE

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anonymous said...
    Guess what is the next? I'm sure you know the answer already, so let's wait and see...


    Actually what is "next"? Please share...thanks

    ReplyDelete
  25. keykok said...
    haha!
    i am ready, "MAYBE" weekend.....

    MAYBE MAYBE MAYBE...wow...wowo...
    MAYBE MAYBE....yuck...yuck yuck.

    ReplyDelete
  26. keykok,
    I believe u really wanna to resign from mca,i notice that you believe in karma.

    All of us know UMNO is a party corrupt to the core,they are raping the rakyat but MCA leaders still keep their eyes close,some even do it together with em,so if you believe in karma,there's no reason for you to remain in MCA,maybe you might choose not to join PR but at least you stop creating more bad karma.

    ReplyDelete
  27. keykok,
    敢讲就要敢作!方为男子汉!!
    rakyat know what you said in yr blog.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Draft your resignation letter and publish in ur blog. Those that agree can action together with keykok, use the same resignation letter only change the name, show something, let people know that they are doing wrong thing.

    ReplyDelete
  29. 有......有......

    可别太期待,周末刊登.......

    ReplyDelete
  30. 看到匿名人士一直批评,真的觉得马来西亚完蛋了,如果认为自己是人的话,就光明正大把部落格link起来,像这样,像什么样的东西?
    而且一直针对博主,砍了他踩到你尾巴了!!!

    ReplyDelete
  31. 有一本书的书名叫:

    《感恩折磨你的人》。

    ReplyDelete
  32. Jason said...
    看到匿名人士一直批评,真的觉得马来西亚完蛋了,如果认为自己是人的话,

    Jason, if you think you are "human", then so do i.

    if MCA can be human, why can't I?
    Right?

    ReplyDelete
  33. Jason said...
    看到匿名人士一直批评,真的觉得马来西亚完蛋了,
    That's because BN, everybody know that, even kid. Unless you brain wash your him like your party brain washed you.


    如果认为自己是人的话,
    Already answer this, check it out.

    像这样,像什么样的东西?
    If i am 东西? "What" ARE you? BTW, There is no other way other than "who" and "what", hence, i am here forced to use "what".


    而且一直针对博主,砍了他踩到你尾巴了!!!
    You don't have to worry about this, I think Keykok "know" how to deal with me better. He is my old friend. :)

    Right, keykok?

    ReplyDelete